Warning Signs of Publishing Scams
Unfortunately, the publishing industry has many predatory practices that target aspiring authors. Here are the most common warning signs:
Upfront Fees
Legitimate traditional publishers never charge authors upfront fees. Be wary of publishers that ask for:
- Editorial fees
- Marketing or publicity fees
- ISBN or cover design fees
- Administrative or processing fees
- "Reading fees" to evaluate your manuscript
If a publisher wants money before they've invested in your book, it's a red flag. Legitimate publishers only profit when your book sells.
Guaranteed Bestseller Claims
Be skeptical of any publisher that guarantees your book will become a bestseller or promises specific sales numbers. No one can guarantee bestseller status, and these promises are often fraudulent.
Ownership of Your Rights
Predatory publishers may try to claim ownership of your intellectual property indefinitely. Beware of:
- Contracts giving the publisher all rights to your work
- Requirements to sign away foreign rights, subsidiary rights, or audio rights
- Unreasonably long contract terms with no reversion clause
- Pressure to assign your copyright to the publisher
Lack of Transparency
Legitimate publishers are transparent about their process, royalty rates, and contract terms. Be cautious if a publisher:
- Won't provide a written contract
- Refuses to explain royalty calculations
- Won't disclose how many books have sold
- Won't provide sales statements or financial reports
Unrealistic Royalty Rates
Royalty rates vary, but be wary of rates that seem too good to be true or suspiciously low. Predatory publishers may offer high percentages they have no intention of actually paying.
Legitimate vs. Predatory Publishers
| Legitimate Publisher | Predatory Publisher |
|---|---|
| No upfront fees from authors | Charges editing, design, or marketing fees |
| Clear, transparent contract terms | Vague or confusing contracts |
| Reasonable rights reversion clause | Indefinite rights ownership |
| Regular royalty statements and payments | Irregular or no payment statements |
| Professional editing and design included | Low-quality production values |
| Realistic expectations about marketing | Guarantees or unrealistic promises |
| Professional communication and support | Pressure tactics and poor communication |
How Reynolds Communications Does Business
At Publish with Reynolds Communications, we operate with integrity and transparency:
- We never charge authors upfront fees of any kind
- We invest our own resources in editing, design, and production
- We provide clear, fair contracts with reasonable terms
- Authors retain ownership of their intellectual property
- We offer fair royalty rates and regular accounting statements
- We work with each author to develop a marketing and distribution strategy
- We maintain professional, transparent communication throughout the process
- We honor our obligations and stand behind our authors
Tips for Protecting Yourself
If you're considering publishing your work, follow these best practices:
- Do your research: Check publisher reviews on industry sites and author forums
- Read the contract carefully: Have a literary attorney review it if possible
- Ask questions: A legitimate publisher will answer any questions about their process
- Get everything in writing: Verbal promises mean nothing legally
- Verify credentials: Check if the publisher is established and has published other books
- Never pay upfront: Legitimate publishers don't charge authors
- Trust your instincts: If something feels off, it probably is
- Network with other authors: Join writing groups and ask about publishers' reputations
- Consider traditional vs. self-publishing: Understand the differences and which is right for you
Helpful Resources
These organizations provide valuable information about publishing and help identify scams:
- Writer Beware - Specializes in identifying and tracking publishing scams and literary scheme
- Authors Guild - Advocacy organization for authors with contract review services
- Children's Writer and Illustrator's Network - Resources for children's book authors
- Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America (SFWA) - Industry standards and warnings
- Mystery Writers of America (MWA) - Resources for mystery and crime writers
Reporting Scams
If you encounter a publishing scam, report it to:
- Writer Beware (writer-beware@sfwa.org)
- The Federal Trade Commission (ftc.gov/complaint)
- Your state's Attorney General office
- Internet Fraud Complaint Center (ic3.gov)
Questions? Contact Us
If you have questions about our publishing process or want to verify our credentials and practices, we're happy to help:
Reynolds Communications
450 Park Avenue
New York, NY 10022, USA
Email: authors@publishwithrc.com
Phone: 1-800-PUBLISH